Did you know that, according to Medscape, scaphoid fractures account for approximately 10% of all hand fractures and up to 60-70% of all carpal fractures? These injuries often result from falls onto an outstretched hand, leading to wrist pain that can be easily overlooked.
Timely and appropriate treatment for fractured scaphoid bones is crucial to prevent complications such as nonunion or avascular necrosis. Today let’s look at anatomy of the scaphoid, recognize fracture symptoms, explore both non-surgical and surgical treatment options, and outline the recovery process to ensure optimal healing.
Understanding the Scaphoid and How It Breaks
The scaphoid is a small bone in the wrist that plays a key role in movement and stability. A fracture in this bone can be difficult to detect but can lead to long-term problems if left untreated.
There are three primary reasons why scaphoid fractures are unique:
- The bone’s shape and location make it prone to injury
- Limited blood supply slows healing
- Delayed diagnosis increases the risk of complications
The Bone’s Shape and Location
The scaphoid sits between the thumb and forearm, making it a key part of wrist movement. It helps transfer force from the hand to the arm, which makes it vulnerable to fractures.
Falls onto an outstretched hand often result in breaks, especially in sports or activities that involve sudden impact. Since the scaphoid is not a large, solid bone, breaks can be small and difficult to detect. Unlike other wrist fractures, this one does not always cause immediate swelling or bruising, which can make diagnosis challenging.
Limited Blood Supply Slows Healing
Blood flow to the scaphoid is weaker than in other wrist bones. Most of its blood supply comes from the radial artery, but circulation to the lower part of the bone is poor.
If a fracture disrupts blood flow, healing can take much longer. In some cases, the bone may not heal at all, leading to a condition known as nonunion. Without treatment, this can cause ongoing pain and arthritis in the wrist.
Delayed Diagnosis Increases the Risk of Complications
Since pain from a scaphoid fracture is often mild at first, many people assume they have only sprained their wrist. Some fractures do not show up on X-rays right away, leading to a missed or delayed diagnosis.
Without early treatment, the bone can shift out of place, making recovery more difficult. If the fracture does not heal properly, surgery may be needed to restore function and prevent long-term damage.
Recognizing a Scaphoid Fracture: Symptoms and Diagnosis
A scaphoid fracture can be easy to miss at first. Many people assume they have a minor wrist sprain and ignore the pain. There are three key signs that suggest a scaphoid fracture:
- Pain in the anatomical snuffbox
- Swelling and stiffness in the wrist
- Difficulty gripping or moving the thumb
Pain in the Anatomical Snuffbox
One of the most common scaphoid fracture symptoms is pain in the anatomical snuffbox. This is a small, triangular area on the thumb side of the wrist. Pressing on this spot usually causes sharp pain if the scaphoid is broken.
The pain may be mild at first but often worsens when moving the wrist or gripping objects. Many people notice discomfort when pushing off a surface or trying to lift something heavy.
Swelling and Stiffness in the Wrist
Swelling is not always obvious after a scaphoid fracture. Some people experience only mild puffiness near the base of the thumb. In other cases, the wrist may appear slightly larger on one side.
Stiffness is another sign that should not be ignored. If the wrist feels locked or difficult to move, it may indicate a fracture rather than a simple sprain. Bruising is less common with this type of injury, which is one reason the fracture is often overlooked.
Difficulty Gripping or Moving the Thumb
A fractured scaphoid can make gripping objects painful or difficult. The thumb may feel weak, or certain motions may cause sharp pain. Rotating the wrist, such as when turning a doorknob, can be uncomfortable.
Some people find that their grip strength decreases over time, making daily tasks harder. If these symptoms persist after a fall or injury, a medical evaluation is needed.
Diagnosing a Scaphoid Fracture
Doctors usually begin with a physical exam to check for scaphoid fracture symptoms. X-rays are the first step in confirming the injury, but small fractures may not appear right away.
If symptoms continue and the X-ray does not show a break, a doctor may recommend wearing a cast and taking another X-ray in one to two weeks. More advanced imaging, such as MRI or CT scans, can detect fractures that are not visible in standard X-rays. Early diagnosis is important for healing a broken scaphoid and preventing complications like nonunion or arthritis.
Treatment for Fractured Scaphoid: Non-Surgical Options
Not all scaphoid fractures require surgery. If the bone remains in place, healing can occur with proper immobilization. There are three main non-surgical approaches to treating a scaphoid fracture:
- Casting for stable fractures
- Splinting for minor or suspected fractures
- Monitoring and follow-up imaging
Casting for Stable Fractures
A cast is the most common treatment for a non-displaced scaphoid fracture. Doctors use a thumb spica cast, which covers the forearm, wrist, and thumb. This type of cast keeps the bone from moving while it heals.
The length of time in a cast depends on the location of the break. Fractures closer to the thumb tend to heal faster, often in six to eight weeks.
Breaks in the middle of the bone or closer to the wrist can take longer, sometimes up to 12 weeks. The cast may be fiberglass or plaster. Fiberglass is lighter and more durable, while plaster molds better to the wrist.
Some doctors use a waterproof liner so patients can shower without damaging the cast. Regular checkups are needed to make sure the bone is healing properly. If healing does not progress as expected, further treatment may be needed.
Splinting for Minor or Suspected Fractures
In some cases, a full cast is not needed right away. If a fracture is suspected but does not appear on an initial X-ray, a doctor may recommend a splint.
It allows some movement but keeps the wrist stable enough to prevent further injury. A follow-up X-ray or MRI is usually scheduled within one to two weeks. If a fracture is confirmed, a cast is applied. If no fracture is found, the splint can be removed once the pain subsides.
Splints may also be used for very minor fractures or stress injuries to the scaphoid. These cases often heal within a few weeks, but careful monitoring is necessary to ensure the bone does not shift.
Monitoring and Follow-Up Imaging
Healing a broken scaphoid requires patience. Even with proper treatment, some fractures heal slowly. Doctors use follow-up imaging to check progress. X-rays are common, but in some cases, an MRI or CT scan may be needed.
The tests help confirm that the bone is fusing properly. If healing does not occur within the expected time frame, a doctor may recommend additional support, such as a longer period in a cast or a bone stimulator.
Surgical Treatment for a Fractured Scaphoid
When the bone is displaced or has poor blood flow, surgery may be needed. There are three common reasons surgery is recommended for a scaphoid fracture:
- The bone is displaced and will not heal in the correct position
- The fracture is not healing with non-surgical treatment
- There is poor blood supply to the scaphoid
The Bone Is Displaced and Will Not Heal in the Correct Position
A displaced fracture means the broken ends of the bone have shifted apart. In these cases, a cast cannot hold the pieces together well enough for proper healing.
During surgery, a doctor realigns the bone and secures it with a screw or pin. This helps the bone heal in the right position and prevents future wrist problems.
Most procedures use a small screw that stays in the bone permanently. This screw stabilizes the scaphoid while allowing limited movement during recovery.
Some fractures require additional support with pins, which may be removed after healing. Surgery is usually done through a small incision, either on the front or back of the wrist. The approach depends on the location and type of fracture.
The Fracture Is Not Healing With Non-Surgical Treatment
Some fractures fail to heal after weeks in a cast. This is called a nonunion. If follow-up X-rays or scans show no healing progress, surgery may be the next step. The procedure involves placing a screw in the bone to hold it together. If needed, the surgeon may add a bone graft to stimulate healing.
A bone graft is taken from another part of the body, usually the hip or wrist. It is placed around the fracture to encourage new bone growth.
The technique improves healing in cases where the scaphoid struggles to repair itself. The added bone tissue strengthens the area and increases the chances of full recovery.
There Is Poor Blood Supply to the Scaphoid
The scaphoid has a limited blood supply, which can slow healing. In some fractures, blood flow is completely cut off, leading to a condition called avascular necrosis.
When this happens, the bone tissue begins to die. Without treatment, this can cause wrist pain, stiffness, and arthritis.
To restore blood supply, a surgeon may perform a vascularized bone graft. This type of graft includes small blood vessels that help nourish the scaphoid while it heals.
The graft is often taken from the forearm and placed into the damaged bone. This approach increases the chances of successful healing and prevents long-term wrist damage.
Recovery After Surgery
Healing a broken scaphoid with surgery usually takes several months. The wrist is kept in a splint or cast for a few weeks to protect the bone. Physical therapy is often needed to restore movement and strength.
Most people regain full wrist function, but the healing process can take longer if the fracture was severe or involved a bone graft. Regular follow-up visits help track progress and ensure proper recovery.
Physical Therapy and Strengthening After a Scaphoid Fracture
Once the scaphoid has healed, the focus shifts to regaining wrist strength and mobility. Stiffness and weakness are common after weeks of immobilization.
There are three main goals of therapy after scaphoid fracture recovery:
- Regaining wrist flexibility
- Improving grip strength
- Building endurance for daily activities
Regaining Wrist Flexibility
A scaphoid fracture often leads to stiffness in the wrist and thumb. Since the hand has been in a cast or splint for weeks, the surrounding muscles and ligaments tighten.
Stretching exercises help restore normal movement. Gentle wrist bends, rotations, and finger stretches are introduced first.
Over time, therapy includes weight-bearing movements to help the joint adapt to daily use. Some people regain flexibility quickly, while others need months of gradual improvement.
Improving Grip Strength
Holding objects, making a fist, or twisting the wrist can feel weak after a scaphoid fracture. Strength-building exercises help rebuild the muscles in the wrist and hand.
Therapists often recommend squeezing a soft ball, using resistance bands, or gripping light weights. These exercises start with low intensity and gradually increase as the wrist becomes stronger. Grip strength is an important part of scaphoid fracture recovery, as it helps with everyday tasks like opening jars or carrying bags.
Building Endurance for Daily Activities
After weeks of limited use, the wrist may feel tired with simple movements. Daily tasks like typing, writing, or lifting objects can feel awkward at first. Therapy focuses on improving endurance through repetitive exercises.
Small, frequent movements help the wrist adapt to regular use again. People recovering from surgery or a severe fracture may need longer therapy sessions to regain full function.
Wrist Fracture Treatment
Proper treatment for fractured scaphoid bones is essential for full recovery and long-term wrist function.
We Fix Hands! At Hand Surgery Specialists of Texas, we provide expert care for hand, wrist, and elbow conditions using advanced, minimally invasive techniques.
Our skilled orthopedic hand specialists offer top-quality treatment at our locations in River Oaks, Webster, North Houston, Katy/Sugarland, and Baytown. Let us restore your hand health!
Get in touch today to find out how we can help with your fractured scaphoid!
